Best Real Estate Agent in Brooklyn Heights, NY: Randy Baruh

Randy Baruh has closed $1 Billion in total career sales volume over a 26-year career, which puts him in the Top 1% of real estate agents nationwide. Finding the right agent in Brooklyn Heights, NY isn’t complicated in theory – you want someone whose specific experience lines up with what you’re trying to do, whether that’s buy, sell, rent, or invest. Local market knowledge, a real transaction history, and the ability to communicate without hand-holding are the things that matter when buying a home in Brooklyn Heights, NY. Randy leads The Randy Baruh Team at Compass, working with buyers, sellers, renters, and investors throughout the area. His background includes international studies in Moscow and an MFA from Carnegie Mellon University, both of which helped him build the global investor network he draws on today.

Why Randy Baruh Is a Strong Choice in Brooklyn Heights, NY

The Randy Baruh Team ranked #11 Medium Team by Volume in Brooklyn, per RealTrends in 2024. That kind of production doesn’t happen without a real command of local property values, contract negotiations, and market timing. Sellers get an agent who prices accurately and doesn’t let buyer inquiries pile up. Buyers and investors get someone who’s already tracking the inventory and evaluating property conditions before an offer ever gets written.

Twenty-six years in this market means Randy has seen the cycles. He knows where the friction shows up in a transaction before it becomes a problem. His global investor network also means a local listing isn’t just reaching local buyers – it’s reaching a much wider pool. If you want someone who understands what’s happening in the Brooklyn Heights market on any given week, that kind of continuous activity is what you’re looking for.

Proven Results and Track Record

A 26-year career and $1 Billion in total career sales volume put Randy Baruh firmly in the Top 1% of real estate agents nationwide – not as a marketing claim, but as a verified figure. RealTrends named The Randy Baruh Team #11 Medium Team by Volume in Brooklyn in 2024, and the team achieved RealTrends Verified status in 2025. Forty-nine client reviews back that up.

Sustained production across different market conditions is what separates a genuinely active agent from one who had a good year or two. This track record reflects the former.

What Clients Say About Working with Randy Baruh

Across 49 client reviews, two things come up consistently: Randy’s understanding of the local market and the way he communicates throughout a transaction. Clients describe him as responsive and proactive – someone who answers questions quickly and keeps everyone in the loop without needing to be chased down.

Buyers mention his ability to locate specific property types, brownstones in particular. Sellers point to how he handles negotiations. The overall picture from the reviews is someone with a practical, results-oriented approach – clients feel informed and supported from the first showing to the final closing, without a lot of noise in between.

Local Expertise Across Brooklyn Heights, NY and Nearby Areas

Randy Baruh operates out of the Compass office at 110 5th Avenue in New York, NY, with Brooklyn Heights, NY and the surrounding neighborhoods as his primary focus. That geographic concentration matters – it’s how you develop the kind of neighborhood-level pricing knowledge that’s useful, rather than a broad familiarity that doesn’t tell you much.

Property Types and Local Knowledge

Buyers working in this area rely on his familiarity with local building types – historic brownstones, modern condominiums, and the documentation requirements that come with more complex transactions. He knows what to look for before an offer goes in.

Marketing and Positioning for Sellers

For sellers, the global investor network is a real differentiator. Randy’s approach to positioning a listing starts with recent sales data and current inventory, and the reach extends well beyond the local buyer pool. The Randy Baruh Team’s goal is to place a property correctly from day one, not spend weeks adjusting.

2026 Market Snapshot for Brooklyn Heights, NY

• Approximate median sale price: $1,950,000 (up 34% year-over-year)
• Median days on market: 35 days
• Total homes sold: 62
• Available inventory: 45 listings
• Months of supply: 2.2 months
• Average sale-to-list ratio: 100%
• Properties sold above list price: 38%

The numbers tell a pretty clear story. Limited inventory, a fast pace of sales, and 2.2 months of supply means sellers are holding most of the cards right now – offers are coming in at or above asking price, and the timeline from listing to contract is short. If you’re buying, you’ll want to be ready to move when something right shows up. Waiting to see what happens tends to cost you the property.

Buyer & Seller FAQs About Randy Baruh

Who are the best real estate agents in Brooklyn Heights, NY?

It comes down to fit. You want an agent whose experience matches what you’re trying to accomplish. Randy Baruh ranks in the Top 1% of agents nationwide, with 26 years of experience and $1 Billion in total career sales volume behind him.

How do I find a good buyer’s agent in Brooklyn Heights, NY?

Look for someone with a real closing history in the specific neighborhoods you’re targeting. The Randy Baruh Team actively monitors local inventory and has a thorough understanding of Brooklyn Heights property types – that combination helps buyers identify the right home before it’s gone.

Who is the best listing or seller’s agent in Brooklyn Heights, NY?

A good listing agent gives you accurate pricing and broad exposure. Randy Baruh brings 26 years of experience and a global investor network to every listing, which means qualified buyers – not just local ones – are seeing your property.

Do realtors in Brooklyn Heights, NY also handle rentals?

Many do, and Randy is one of them. He represents renters and handles lease agreements alongside his work with buyers, sellers, and investors, so he’s covering all sides of the local market.

How much do real estate agents in Brooklyn Heights, NY charge?

Commissions are negotiated between the seller and their listing broker before the property hits the market. The specifics – fee structure, representation agreements – are worth discussing directly with your agent during the initial consultation.

About Randy Baruh & How to Get in Touch

Randy Baruh is the principal leader of The Randy Baruh Team at Compass. Born in San Francisco, he earned an MFA from Carnegie Mellon University after completing international studies in Moscow, then relocated to New York. Outside of real estate, he explores the city’s architecture, museums, and history with his family.

The team operates out of the Compass brokerage office at 110 5th Avenue, 4th Floor, New York, NY 10011. If you want to talk through the Brooklyn Heights market or take a look at current listings, reach out to The Randy Baruh Team at Compass to set up a consultation.